A contract dispute may start with performance issues. Then the other side may raise allegations under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA). That shift may expand the issues beyond breach. It may also affect remedies and case strategy. If you operate a business in Texas, it can help to recognize when a disagreement over terms might develop into a statutory claim.
Conduct that converts a contract dispute into a deceptive trade claim
A failure to perform does not, by itself, necessarily create liability under Texas’s deceptive trade law. Courts often look for conduct that goes beyond a broken promise. The focus often turns to representations made in the course of trade or commerce.
Your risk of facing a deceptive trade claim may increase when your conduct involves the following:
-
Making factual statements about quality, cost or capability that later appear inaccurate
-
Failing to disclose known information while intending to induce the deal
-
Describing goods or services in a way that may create a false impression
-
Representing that goods or services have characteristics or benefits that they may not have
The issue may shift from nonperformance to misleading conduct. Statements in proposals, sales meetings and written communications may receive close attention. The analysis often focuses on whether the other party relied on those statements when entering the transaction.
Exposure that follows a deceptive trade claim in litigation
If a claimant qualifies as a consumer under Texas law, the statute may allow remedies beyond contract damages. In some cases, a court may award additional damages if the conduct meets a higher standard. The DTPA also requires written notice before filing suit in many situations. That step may affect timing and settlement discussions.
Discovery may broaden to include marketing materials, internal communications and sales practices. This wider review may increase cost and disruption. Early evaluation of the facts and the claimant’s status can help you gauge exposure and plan your response.
Evaluating your position before the dispute expands
If your contract dispute begins to include alleged misstatements or omissions, you may consider slowing your response. Gather key communications tied to the transaction, including proposals, emails and marketing materials.
Review what you communicated and where the accounts differ. It may also help to evaluate whether the other party could qualify as a consumer under Texas law, since that issue can influence the scope of the claim.